Seedrs pleased about FreeAgent IPO but I bet their investors aren’t

Crowdfunding has been looking for a runaway success or two in order to give investors the confidence that investing in unregulated early stage companies can make even unsophisticated investors money. Nothing smacks of success like an IPO so I was excited to see the news of FreeAgent’s AIM IPO take top billing in today’s Seedrs newsletter.

I’m not sure this is such a great advert for crowdfunding though…

“Dear friends,

“I’m pleased to tell you that today Seedrs saw the first IPO by one of our portfolio companies.

FreeAgent, which provides cloud accounting software for freelancers and small businesses, successfully floated on the London Stock Exchange’s AIM and raised £10.7 million in the process. The company had raised £1 million through Seedrs from 695 investors in 2015. These investors now have the choice of continuing to hold their shares or seeking to sell them on AIM at any time.

“We congratulate FreeAgent on this milestone, and we look forward to seeing many more of our businesses move onto the public markets in the future.”

Great. Except is it?

When FreeAgent raised money on Seedrs last year, it was cited by some as a good example of an early stage company that was raising money on better terms than were available through many VCs. Some VCs told me the valuation put on the business was simply too high for where it currently was. Raising money through crowdfunding at seemingly advantageous terms for the business seems like a good idea.

According to Seedrs, the FreeAgent fundraising in July 2015 raised £1.2 million for the business (before professional fees are deducted) and valued the business at about £30 million pre-money:

Freeagent Seedrs Fundraise valuation

(Seedrs Website)

In today’s AIM Listing, FreeAgent Holdings raised,

“£10.7m from institutional investors via a placing of 9,523,810 new ordinary shares, raising gross proceeds of £8.0m for the company, and 3,192,850 existing ordinary shares raising gross proceeds of £2.7m for the selling shareholders, in each case at a placing price of 84p per share.” Press Release.

In other words…

  • July 2015
    • Pre-money valuation was c £30.2 million and the company raised £1.2 million from new shares. (£31.4 million post).
  • November 2016
    • Post-money valuation of the company was £34.4 million AFTER it had raised £10.7 million from institutional shareholders. £8 million of the money went to growing the business (before professional fees are deducted). £2.7 million went to shareholders who were cashing out. (These shareholders weren’t regular investors through Seedrs).

So the value of the shares through Seedrs moved down between July 2015 and November 2016, founder/early investors got to sell some of their stock, advisers have made fees at every step, the company shares are now listed on an illiquid platform where they still might not be able to sell shares at a price they are comfortable with.

Winners: The advisers and early shareholders have made money.

Losers: Shareholders in Seedrs round.

Jury Out: The company has raised money for growth, it may find that raising additional capital on AIM becomes a problem for the company however if it needs to go back to the market.

This is the Seedrs November investor update.

The BLN is now Business of Software

Business of Software runs conferences for people that build great software businesses and products. To access talks online, hear about new events, contact speakers and stay in touch with great ideas, share your email address with us.